Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar’s 53-Point Absence Forces Avalanche Overhaul

Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar's 53-Point Absence Forces Avalanche Overhaul AI-generated image

With Nathan MacKinnon out a month and Cale Makar sidelined two weeks, the 12-6-3 Avalanche must trade high-event rush offense for compact 5-on-5 survival.

Losing 53 combined points in a single second period at Canadian Tire Centre would break the spine of almost any roster in the NHL, yet the real test for the Colorado Avalanche starts in the neutral zone, not the trainer’s room. When Cale Makar left Thursday’s 4-3 overtime loss to the Ottawa Senators after a four-second shift at 10:44 of the second and a brief 23-second return ending with 5:20 left, and Nathan MacKinnon followed him down the tunnel at the 8:15 mark after taking an Artem Zub cross-check to the hip on an attempted reverse hit, Colorado lost the two greatest transition engines in modern hockey. Now MacKinnon is out for a month and Makar is sidelined for two weeks with a lower-body soft-tissue issue he had been playing through since leaving practice on November 8.

My view on how Colorado survives the next 30 days comes down to zone-exit geometry and 5-on-5 possession math. Without MacKinnon’s 30 points in 20 games and Makar’s 23 points and 22:25 of average ice time across 19 contests, head coach Jared Bednar cannot run his high-tempo, stretch-and-attack rush system. The Avalanche have to compress the ice, slow their pace to a crawl, and survive on low-event defensive structure untilMakars’s edges return in late November.

Why the 5-on-5 Transition Math Forces a Complete Tactical Pivot

Look at what MacKinnon and Makar actually do to an opponent’s forecheck. Both players force opposing third forwards (the F3) to back off the offensive blue line out of sheer terror of getting burned on a controlled breakout. MacKinnon, who won the Hart Trophy in 2023-24 and finished as a finalist last season with a League-leading 53 goals, 127 points, and a plus-57 rating, generates clean zone entries with speed that collapses defensive gaps before the defensemen can set their pivots. Makar, a two-time Norris Trophy winner and Conn Smythe MVP who already owns 530 points in 489 career regular-season games, breaks pressure with lateral Mohawk turns in his own end that erase two forecheckers at once.

“Probably the most important is the 5-on-5 offense that they create,” Bednar told NHL.com on Saturday before facing Montreal. “We can be playing an OK game, chances equal, tight game, and those guys, like the top players do, will find a way to make a play that’s a difference-maker for you. Whether it’s Cale or ‘Mac,’ or both of them combined, they generally win us a lot of hockey games because of that. So with out that, the rest of the game has to tighten up and get better.”

I look at that quote from Bednar and read a coach who knows his expected goals and Corsi margins at even strength are about to get squeezed. When you pull 53 points of top-end creation out of a lineup simultaneously, plus a top power-play unit that had cashed in 10 goals over its previous 10 games, you cannot ask replacement-level call-ups to replicate high-event rush hockey.

Forward Martin Necas and the Colorado locker room are taking the optimistic view that internal talent alone can absorb the blow. “It’s a big task, but we are all excited for it,” Necas told NHL.com. “We still have good enough players that we can kind of figure (it) out.”

I respect a skilled winger backing his room, yet the roster math says internal elevation creates a massive trickle-down tax across all four lines and three pairings.

How the Elevation Tax Exposes Colorado’s Blue Line Depth

Every time you bump a second-line center or a second-pair defenseman into elite top-unit matchups against the opponent’s best shutdown five-man unit, you weaken the third and fourth tiers behind them. Colorado was already missing rugged defenseman Josh Manson, who landed on long-term injured reserve in late October with an ankle injury that carries an eight-week timeline. On Saturday, defenseman Alex Gagne had to make his NHL debut in Makar’s spot while Gavin Brindley came up from the AHL Colorado Eagles to fill in up front.

“When I think about those two guys, it’s like every matchup, they take it on, now someone else has to be able to step up and do that,” Bednar said via NHL.com. “And then you are losing the depth down the lineup as you kind of do that because everyone is elevated.”

That elevation problem is the exact reason Colorado’s front office went shopping on the waiver wire Sunday and claimed veteran defenseman Mike Reilly off waivers from the Carolina Hurricanes. Reilly brings an $850,000 cap hit, two assists in eight games this season with Carolina, and 135 career points across 468 NHL games. In my evaluation, claiming Reilly is a classic analytical band-aid… you cannot replace Makar’s elite offensive ceiling, so you add a veteran puck-mover who can execute a clean first pass out of the defensive zone without icing the puck under heavy forecheck pressure.

Saturday night’s 4-1 road win over the Montreal Canadiens at the Bell Centre offered the exact blueprint for how this shorthanded group has to play. Montreal entered the night on a 12-game point streak (9-0-3), and Colorado suffocated them with compact five-man layers, 25 saves from Mackenzie Blackwood, even-strength goals from Fedor Svechkov and Brock Nelson, a power-play tally from Artturi Lehkonen, and an empty-netter from Nicolas Roy.

“Missing two of the best players in the world, you can’t really replace that,” Lehkonen said Saturday per NHL.com. “They are a huge part of our offense. Got to find different ways to create offense and score goals today for sure.”

Sitting at 12-6-3, Colorado bought itself a cushion with that road victory in Montreal. If Reilly stabilizes the bottom four on Wednesday night at 10 p.m. ET against the Utah Mammoth and Blackwood holds opponents under three goals a night for the next 14 days, Makar will step back onto the blue line in late November with the Avalanche still holding a top-three division seed while MacKinnon heals for December.

Share this article