**GM Fitzgerald Out as Devils Eye ‘New Direction’**
—
### **The Departure of Tom Fitzgerald and the Context of a Franchise Rebuilding**
Tom Fitzgerald’s departure from his role as general manager of the New Jersey Devils marks a pivotal moment in franchise history, one that comes at a time when expectations are high and results are low. The team, which made the playoffs for the first time since 2012 during the 2022-23 season before falling to the Carolina Hurricanes in the second round, now finds itself outside the postseason picture with five games remaining. While the Devils (40-34-3) are still mathematically eligible for the playoffs, they are seven points out of the final Eastern Conference berth and on pace for a 79-point season — their lowest total since 2015.
The decision to part ways with Fitzgerald was reportedly mutual between him and co-owner David Blitzer. “Tom and I had a thoughtful conversation today and agreed it was time to move in a new direction,” said Blitzer in a statement released Monday morning. The language suggests a calculated, strategic move rather than an abrupt dismissal, though the timing raises questions about whether Fitzgerald’s tenure will be viewed as a success or a failure.
Fitzgerald, who assumed the role of interim GM in January 2020 and was elevated to full-time status later that summer, had been tasked with steering the Devils through a transition period. He inherited an organization that had missed the playoffs for four consecutive seasons (2016–2020) and had seen its core group of young stars — including captain Nico Hischier, Jack Hughes, and Taylor Hall — evolve into one of the most promising rosters in the NHL.
—
### **The Fitzgerald Era: A Tale of Progress and Disappointment**
Fitzgerald’s tenure can be broken down into two distinct phases: an initial period of stabilization and a subsequent push toward contention that fell short. His first task was to restore stability after years of mismanagement under former GM Ray Shero, whose hiring in 2015 had been seen as a failed attempt at reinvigorating the franchise.
By the time Fitzgerald became interim GM in early 2020, the Devils were in disarray — with no playoff hopes and a roster that had stagnated. He inherited a team with cap flexibility due to several impending free-agent departures and was tasked with building for the future. His decisions during this period were largely defensive: retaining top young players like Hughes, Hischier, and Hall; avoiding costly extensions; and allowing some of the organization’s older, overpaid veterans to walk.
The 2021-22 season saw the Devils finish with a record of 37-34-7 (81 points), which was good for seventh in the Metropolitan Division. While it wasn’t enough to earn a playoff berth, it was a step in the right direction and laid the groundwork for what would come next.
The turning point arrived during the 2022-23 season when Fitzgerald made one of his most impactful moves — acquiring star forward Timo Meier from the San Jose Sharks. The trade not only provided the Devils with a dynamic, two-way forward but also signaled a shift in philosophy: the team was no longer simply waiting for its core to mature; it was aggressively trying to surround them with proven talent.
That season saw the Devils finish 51-20-7 (109 points), setting a franchise record for points in a single season and earning a playoff berth for the first time since 2012. The team’s success wasn’t just a product of Fitzgerald’s trade moves — it was also fueled by the growth of Hischier, Hughes, and Hall, who were entering their prime years.
—
### **The Playoff Run: A Step Forward, But Not Enough**
The Devils’ playoff run in 2023 ended in disappointment. After being seeded second in the Metropolitan Division, they faced the Hurricanes in the second round — a matchup that had the potential to be one of the most exciting in recent memory. The series was highly competitive, with the Devils even taking a 3-1 lead at one point, but they ultimately fell in five games.
While the loss was painful, it wasn’t necessarily a reflection of Fitzgerald’s decision-making. The team still had room for growth and its core group of young stars was clearly on the rise. In fact, the Devils were widely regarded as one of the most promising teams in the league heading into 2023-24 — with Hughes entering his prime, Hischier evolving into a top-two center in the NHL, and Hall finally healthy after several injury-plagued seasons.
That optimism was short-lived. The 2023-24 campaign has been a regression for the Devils. Their record of 40-34-3 (83 points) is a drop from their previous season, and they are currently on pace to miss the playoffs for the first time since 2019.
The question that remains is whether Fitzgerald’s leadership in this period was ultimately flawed or if he simply inherited a team that regressed due to factors beyond his control. His trade moves during this season have been limited — he signed some free agents (notably, goaltender Mackenzie Blackwood and forward Adam Pelech) but has not made any major blockbuster deals.
—
### **The Metrics: A Mixed Record**
Fitzgerald’s tenure can be evaluated through a lens of advanced metrics, which provide clarity on whether his decisions were effective or not. Over the past four seasons (2021-24), the Devils have had an average Corsi For percentage (CF%) of 53.9% — slightly above league average but not indicative of sustained success.
The team’s expected goals for (xGF) and against (xGA) per game in this span have averaged at 2.81 and 2.70, respectively — again, a slight edge but not overwhelming. The Devils’ 5-on-5 net rating during Fitzgerald’s tenure has been +0.9 points per 60 minutes, which is above average but not elite.
The team’s underlying performance has shown signs of improvement in key areas: their defensive structure under head coach Lindy Ruff (now replaced by PJ Stock) was among the best in the league last season, and their scoring depth has increased significantly with players like Meier and Alexander Holtz contributing at a high level.
However, when it comes to actual results — wins, playoff appearances, and overall performance — Fitzgerald’s record is mixed. He led the Devils back into the playoffs after four years of absence but was unable to secure a deep run or establish sustained success. The team has regressed in 2023-24, and the lack of major trade activity this offseason raises questions about whether Fitzgerald had already been handed the “new direction” script.
—
### **The Players’ Perspective: A Team That Believes But Is Frustrated**
Nico Hischier and Jack Hughes — two of the Devils’ most important players — have publicly expressed their admiration for Fitzgerald, even as they voice frustration over the team’s recent performance.
“I think he’s done a pretty good job of that over the years,” said Hughes in an interview with reporters earlier this season. “Most of it comes down to the players. We’re the ones going on the ice, competing every night. We’re the ones that can change the outcome of a hockey game.”
That sentiment is revealing: Hughes and Hischier recognize Fitzgerald’s contributions but also understand that they are ultimately responsible for the team’s performance. The Devils have a core group of young players who are now in their prime — yet they have not reached the level of success expected from them.
The frustration among fans, meanwhile, has been palpable throughout this season. Blitzer himself acknowledged that disappointment is widespread: “I recognize we have not delivered in the way you expect and deserve and I understand and share in your frustration.”
That admission suggests that Fitzgerald’s departure was not just a move to realign management but also an acknowledgment of fan dissatisfaction with the team’s performance.
—
### **What Went Wrong?**
There are several factors that could explain why the Devils have struggled this season despite having one of the most promising rosters in the league. The first is player development — while Hughes, Hischier, and Hall have all made strides, their consistency remains an issue. Hughes has been excellent at times but has also had stretches where his play has regressed. Hischier has taken on more leadership responsibilities but still hasn’t fully unlocked his offensive potential.
The second factor is the team’s depth — while Meier and Holtz have performed well, the Devils lack reliable scoring from their bottom-six forwards. This has led to a reliance on their top line (Hischier-Hughes-Hall) to carry the offense, which can be unsustainable over the long haul.
Thirdly, there is the issue of goaltending — Mackenzie Blackwood has been inconsistent this season and has struggled with his workload. The Devils have also failed to develop any strong backup options behind him.
Finally, it’s worth considering that Fitzgerald may not have had enough time or resources to build a truly competitive team. He was brought in as an interim GM during a transitional period — one where the Devils were still figuring out their identity and direction. While he did make progress, the regression of 2023-24 could be attributed to a combination of factors beyond his control.
—
### **The Path Forward: What’s Next for the Devils?**
With Fitzgerald gone, the Devils now face an uncertain future — one that will likely involve significant changes in leadership and strategy. The team is entering what Blitzer called “a critical offseason,” and it remains unclear whether they will pursue a rebuild or continue trying to compete.
One possibility is that the Devils may look for a new general manager with more experience in building competitive teams. Fitzgerald was a first-time GM — someone who had never managed an NHL team before assuming the role in 2020. While his tenure showed promise, it also highlighted the challenges of leading a franchise through transformation.
Another possibility is that the Devils may pursue a trade deadline acquisition or a major free-agent signing to improve their chances in the playoffs this season. However, given the timeline and the team’s current performance, such moves would be reactive rather than strategic.
The most likely outcome is a full-scale rebuild — one that involves trading away some of the team’s young stars for assets (draft picks, prospects) and starting over with a new group of players. This approach could allow the Devils to reset their timeline and build around a new core, but it would also mean missing out on another opportunity to make the playoffs.
—
### **Conclusion: A Leadership Change in Search of a Strategy**
Tom Fitzgerald’s departure from the New Jersey Devils is not just a personnel move — it is a statement about where the franchise currently stands. The team has made progress under his leadership, but it has also failed to reach the level of success that fans and owners alike expected.
Fitzgerald was tasked with steering the Devils back into contention after years of stagnation, and he did make strides in that direction — but not enough to secure long-term stability or sustained success. His departure now opens the door for a new general manager to bring a different vision to the organization.
What remains unclear is whether this leadership change will lead to a true breakthrough or simply another cycle of missed opportunities. The Devils have one of the most talented young cores in the NHL, but talent alone does not guarantee success — it must be paired with effective management and strategic decision-making.
As the team moves forward, it’s worth asking: Was Fitzgerald the right man for the job? Or was he just a temporary placeholder in an organization that still hasn’t found its identity?
Only time will tell.
