Nine years and nearly $400 million is the price of redemption in Queens, and Steve Cohen just slid the entire stack across the table before the rest of Major League Baseball finished pouring its morning coffee. On Friday, former Mets general manager Jim Duquette dropped a grenade on the hot stove by reporting that New York opened the bidding for two-time American League Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal with a nine-year offer approaching $400 million. After a humid, humiliating 74-88 finish that left my stomach sour just looking at the National League East standings, Cohen and president of baseball operations David Stearns decided that polite negotiation is for franchises content with moral victories.
I look at the wreckage of that 2026 Mets rotation and I see an organization that had zero choice but to detonate the market. You cannot finish dead last in your division with one of the wealthiest owners in American sports and walk into November pitching meetings preaching patience. Cohen brought Stearns, manager Andy Green, and pitching coach Justin Willard to Orange County on Monday to sit across from Skubal on the week of his 30th birthday, and my read on this opening salvo is simple: New York is trying to suffocate the Los Angeles Dodgers, the Toronto Blue Jays, and the San Diego Padres before the December 1 collective bargaining agreement expiration freezes the transaction wire.
“There has been a constant buzz since Vegas and multiple MLB sources have since confirmed that the initial Mets offer on Tarik Skubal was 9 years almost $400 million,” Duquette posted on X on Friday. “That offer itself would far exceed the total dollars and would be the highest AAV for a free agent SP ever with likely other offers to follow. Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander $43.33M are the records currently.”
The Nine-Year Math That Terrifies Front-Office Cowards
Look closely at the numbers Duquette laid out, because the sticker shock is blinding people to the actual leverage play. An offer approaching $400 million over nine seasons carries an average annual value around $44.44 million, shattering Yoshinobu Yamamoto’s $325 million total value record with the Dodgers while topping the $43.33 million annual watermark Cohen himself set with Scherzer in 2021 and Verlander in 2022. The skeptics argue that handing nine guaranteed years to a 30-year-old power left-hander with a 2022 Tommy John scar on his elbow is reckless roster malpractice that will leave New York paying $44 million a year for dead velocity through age 39.
That cautious front-office argument ignores both the December 1 lockout clock and what makes Skubal structurally different from aging flame-throwers. Skubal did not just overpower hitters in 2026 on his way to a 12-7 record, a 2.72 ERA, and 186 strikeouts across 158.2 innings split between Detroit and Los Angeles… he strangled them with elite command, posting a 0.96 WHIP built on high-velocity four-seam ride at the top of the zone paired with lethal secondary separation that keeps barrels off the ball even when he economizes his pitch count. After his consecutive AL Cy Young campaigns in 2024 (18-4, 2.39 ERA) and 2025 (13-6, 2.21 ERA), he went 5-2 with a 2.61 ERA in 10 starts after the deadline trade to the Dodgers, proving his arsenal translates immediately under postseason-race pressure in the National League.
I refuse to pretend that years eight and nine of a nine-year pitching contract are ever supposed to look efficient on a spreadsheet. You pay for the back end of the deal so you can own the front five years of an undisputed ace during your championship window. By stretching the total toward $400 million over nine years instead of packing $300 million into six, Stearns and Cohen hand the market a historic headline figure while keeping the annual luxury-tax hit close to what they already paid Scherzer and Verlander.
Why Los Angeles Cannot Let Steve Cohen Own December
My favorite subplot in this entire bidding war is the cold sweat currently breaking out inside the Dodgers front office. Los Angeles surrendered serious prospect capital at the 2026 trade deadline to rent Skubal for a three-peat push that fell short of a World Series trophy. Letting him walk to Queens four months later without a ring to show for the deadline blockbuster would stand as an unmitigated disaster for a Dodgers machine that prides itself on closing every superstar it touches.
New York Post insider Jon Heyman reported this week that word around the league has Cohen expected to be “all in” for Skubal, noting that the Mets contingent walked out of their Orange County meeting “uber impressed” and with their resolve stronger than ever. That is the sound of an owner who has decided he will never again enter April without a genuine Game 1 starter on the mound. When Cohen, Stearns, Green, and Willard flew west, they went to close, not to window-shop.
Boras will undoubtedly take this $400 million baseline back to the Dodgers, the Blue Jays, the Padres, and the mystery fifth club that met with Skubal over Zoom to squeeze every last dollar out of the final ten days before the CBA expires. Yet with a record-shattering offer now public, Cohen has turned the next week and a half into a public referendum on whether any ownership group in baseball has the stomach to match his checkbook before the December 1 midnight buzzer locks the doors.